
November 6th 2026 By William Ralston In May 2014 Aleksandr Iugov, a 29-year-old Russian, drove six hours from his home in Milan to Burgundy, one of France’s most renowned wine-producing regions. He had an appointment to meet Pierre-Jean Marcus, the director of Wijncuriosa, a Belgian wine retailer, at a hotel. In March Marcus had bought 31 bottles of Domaine Leroy Musigny, an incredibly rare and expensive red wine, from Iugov. But Marcus soon had doubts about their authenticity, after he’d noticed that the wrong alcohol percentage had been printed on the labels.
Marcus had asked Iugov to pick up the bottles and take them to the winery in Burgundy, where they would be authenticated. Just as Iugov and Marcus were about to eat in the hotel restaurant, there was a commotion around them. “Police,” shouted a group of armed officers, before snapping handcuffs on Iugov. The dinner date had been a sting.
Grinning, Iugov claimed they’d got the wrong man. The officers arrested him anyway. In the boot of his car, they found several Russian passports: one for Aleksandr Anikin, his birth name, and two for Iugov, the name he had legally adopted in 2013. (Iugov initially said that Anikin was his twin brother.) The officers also found a dozen bottles, including a Romanée-Conti, one of the most coveted wines in the world.
Wine connoisseurs value it for its bewitching combination of delicacy and depth. The American food critic Richard Olney has described it as “a fabulous thing—mysterious, sensuous, transcendental”. The estate, Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, produces several top wines, but only a few thousand bottles of Romanée-Conti each year; a single one can fetch tens of thousands of euros on initial release and similarly high figures on the secondary market, where many are subsequently traded. Romanée-Conti’s extraordinary value has made it a target for fraudsters.
So too has its minimalist label—white, with no artwork—which makes it easier to counterfeit. Later that night, Iugov was taken to Dijon, Burgundy’s capital, and questioned. I recently met one of the lead investigators from the case for late-night beers at a bar in Dijon. Henri, as I’ll call him, told me that he had been investigating the alleged counterfeiting of Romanée-Conti bottles since 2012, when a few had been identified by a local restaurant owner as possible fakes.
When Henri was first attached to the case, he told me he couldn’t believe it: why would anyone counterfeit wine? From experience, he suspected there were other things that criminals could fake more easily and profitably, like watches, handbags or clothes. But it didn’t take long before Henri became fascinated by the suspicious Romanée-Conti. “We had to learn everything about the bottles, about the wine, about the commerce,” he said.
The investigation soon identified other victims of alleged fraud. It was difficult to connect the crimes because the person selling the Romanée-Conti bottles used different names in different countries. But investigators noticed that he always used the same phone number. They tapped it—which led them to Aleksandr Anikin.
When Henri was first attached to the case, he told me he couldn’t believe it: why would anyone counterfeit wine? The investigators discovered that Anikin, now known as Iugov, had sold more than a hundred bottles of Romanée-Conti to wine retailers across Europe, including Wijncuriosa, between 2011 and 2013. They believed around 20 victims had collectively paid at least €2m, though the total amount was difficult to quantify because Iugov had funnelled the proceeds into several bank accounts, including ones linked to shell companies in Russia and the British Virgin Islands. After his arrest in Burgundy, Iugov claimed that he was unaware that the bottles were fake.
He said he was selling them on behalf of Gideon Weinbaum, a wealthy entrepreneur he knew from Moscow. (Weinbaum died in 2014.) To support his account, Iugov produced financial documents, including one purporting to show a €1.5m ($1.6m) transfer to an account in Weinbaum’s name (investigators believe these had been fabricated after the dates of the supposed transactions). He also produced a photograph of a giant cake, shaped like a Romanée-Conti bottle and bearing the names “Anikin” and “Gideon”. Iugov said that the cake had been a gift to a client from him and Weinbaum in 2012 (emails later obtained by investigators showed that it had actually been ordered by Iugov’s mother from a bakery in 2014).
At Iugov’s trial in January 2017 the judges dismissed his defence, noting his systematic acquisition of Romanée-Conti-related materials; for instance, Iugov had managed to obtain a label from the Domaine via email. He had also refunded nearly €100,000 to Weinbaum’s brother-in-law, who had raised concerns that the 21 bottles of Romanée-Conti he had bought were fake. The judges convicted Iugov of fraud and related offences arising from the movement and sale of counterfeit wines. He was sentenced to four years in prison (of which two were suspended), fined €150,000, and ordered to pay civil damages to several victims, including €300,000 to Domaine de la Romanée-Conti.
At the bar in Dijon, Henri took a long sip of his beer as the staff wiped down the tables around us. He attended Iugov’s trial, and remembered being struck by how convincing and charming the man could be. “The problem isn’t just the bottles, it’s the guy,” Henri said. “Everyone trusts him.
It’s incredible.” He was also begrudgingly impressed by how sophisticated Iugov’s operation seemed compared with other wine-fraud plots he’d researched, which tended to be smaller-scale and managed by lone actors. It was still a “mystery” to him how Iugov co-ordinated the sourcing and filling of the bottles, as well as the sales to buyers: “One person cannot do all that.” (The court had in fact concluded that Iugov wasn’t working alone, yet was unable to establish the identities or roles of his associates.) Henri called Iugov’s approach “organised crime with a commercial mindset”.
Your browser does not support this video. But for all its reach, Iugov’s wine-fraud scheme was still crude compared with those being carried out today. In the dozen years since Iugov was first arrested, wine fraud has become more industrial in scale and scope, with small bands of organised criminals producing more—and more convincing—counterfeit bottles than ever before. Europe’s wine-producing nations have taken note of the growing problem.
In 2020 the French gendarmerie created a specialist unit to tackle wine fraud; in the year to April 2025 it received 150 complaints linked to more than 100 criminal groups. The Italian Carabinieri launched 15 criminal investigations between 2024 and 2026, seizing nearly 400,000 litres of counterfeit wine worth around €2m. (According to Daniele Vescarelli, a commander with the Carabinieri’s Command for the Protection of Agri-Food Products in Italy, these figures are incomplete because other Italian authorities hold additional data on wine-fraud investigations.) Experts fear that counterfeiters are beginning to outmanoeuvre the authorities tasked with stopping them by expanding into mid-tier wines, where huge profits stand to be made from bottles that are worth hundreds of euros but cost barely anything to fake. Amid these industry-wide shifts, Henri and Iugov crossed paths again.
A few years after his arrest in Burgundy, Iugov allegedly made a new and even more sophisticated attempt to sell counterfeit Romanée-Conti bottles; his trial on those allegations is currently pending. “It’s incredible,” Henri told me about the quality of the fakes, shaking his head. More than a third of his career, he noted, had been spent going after the same man. “People keep saying I am always against this guy but…it’s not my fault.”
Wine has been faked “for as long as it has been drunk”, said Rebecca Gibb, the author of a history of the subject. But wine fraud intensified in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when improvements in bottling, corking and transportation allowed wine to become more widely distributed. Fraudsters began passing off cheap or inferior bottles as products from prestigious regions. Wine-producing countries responded by introducing appellation systems, which restrict geographical names to wines made from specific grapes grown in defined areas according to established production standards.
These laws made it easier to distinguish legitimate wines, and gave authorities a stronger basis for prosecuting anyone selling fraudulent ones. But instead of disappearing, wine fraud moved upmarket. After the second world war prices of rare bottles rose, drawing in rich collectors. “A different market was now being deceived, because fine wine was being traded like art,” Gibb said.
And like art, these wine collections were painstakingly built over time: bottles were sought out and acquired, not for immediate consumption but as financial investments, or left to mature until a special occasion. More than a third of his career, Henri noted, had been spent going after the same man. “People keep saying I am always against this guy but…it’s not my fault” Fraudsters began sourcing high-value bottles from bars, restaurants and tasting events to refill with cheaper wine and recork—a scam called refilling “empties”. In the 2000s Rudy Kurniawan, an Indonesian living in Los Angeles, became one of its most successful practitioners, marketing his blends of cheaper vintages as prized releases from the likes of Domaine de la Romanée-Conti.
Kurniawan’s scheme started to unravel in 2008, when he tried to sell dozens of bottles of a wine called Clos Saint-Denis at auction. The vintages dated as far back as 1945—yet Domaine Ponsot, the estate, hadn’t started producing Clos Saint-Denis until 1982. Laurent Ponsot, the winery’s owner, travelled to New York to halt the sale; he later provided evidence for the FBI, which was already investigating Kurniawan. When agents stormed Kurniawan’s home in 2012, they found old bottles soaking in the sink, piles of corks and thousands of fake labels.
In 2014 a federal court sentenced him to ten years in prison, the first conviction in America for wine fraud. Rather than deterring criminals, Kurniawan’s conviction “put wine fraud on the map”, said Bill Edgerton, an American expert in wine authentication. Since then, the financial incentives have only grown, driven by surging demand and limited supply. Unlike most assets, wine is eventually consumed, so the pool of rare bottles steadily shrinks.
At its peak in 2022 the Fine Wine 100 index, which tracks the sale prices of the most sought-after wines on the secondary market, had risen more than 77% since 2010. Even less celebrated wines, priced in the hundreds of euros rather than the thousands, have risen sharply in value over that same period. But it isn’t just the money that attracts fraudsters. According to Maureen Downey, another American wine authenticator, the Kurniawan case also highlighted the limited risks.
No one connected to Kurniawan was ever charged with a crime, including several people believed to have funded his operation. In America a fraud conviction requires proof of criminal intent, something prosecutors couldn’t establish. Downey believes this created a dangerous precedent that fraudsters “can easily set up a fall guy”. The low risk is compounded because the market has few reliable ways of proving whether a bottle is real.
Unlike cars or watches, bottles do not always carry unique identifiers. Provenance, the paper trail of ownership and storage, is often incomplete or missing, especially with older vintages. Much of the trade in fine bottles takes place either through specialist wine merchants or auction houses, where there is no legal obligation to verify authenticity; or through private emails, social media and online forums, where deals depend on trust between the buyer and seller. According to Downey, sellers have a strong i
Texto de economist.com tal como lo publicó, leído de su página y mostrado aquí con el formato de El Autómata. El original, en economist.com · Volver a la noticia de El Autómata