Coffeehouses and the Rise of Science‗ Monir Bounadi† (Job Market Paper) Jens Oehlen‡ [Most recent version here] October 31, 2026 Abstract Historians have long credited coffeehouses, venues for conversation where strangers met across social ranks, with fostering scientific contacts and activity during the Scientific Revolution. We test this claim in seventeenth-century London. Relying on newly geocoded records and a staggered event study across parishes, we find that the opening of the first coffeehouse in a parish is followed by a persistent increase in applied scientists and scientific instrument shops. Effects are concentrated among applied scientists with weak family ties to Oxford and Cambridge.
Social connections that link craft skill to theory increase, and new shops turn toward experimental instruments. Across European cities in the seventeenth century, we similarly find that the numbers of applied mathematics titles and scientific instrument makers rise after a city’s first coffeehouse, relative to cities of similar size and growth. In a quantitative urban model calibrated to our parish- and city-level estimates, coffeehouses account for 31 percent of London’s applied scientists in the half century after the first one opened in 1652. These findings show that social institutions can raise the production and use of knowledge by broadening access to intellectual exchange beyond formal academic networks.
Keywords: Coffeehouses, Scientific Revolution, Knowledge Diffusion, Social Networks JEL Codes: N33, N93, O31, O33, D83, R12 ‗We are grateful to Torsten Persson, David Schönholzer, and David Strömberg for their guidance. We thank Mehdi Amani, Alireza Azampour, Sascha O. Becker, Anne Sofie Beck Knudsen, Iacopo Bianchi, Tessa Bold, Konrad Burchardi, Marcel Caesmann, Gregory Clark, David de la Croix, Merve Demirel, Mitch Downey, Vitalia Eliseeva, Valentin Figueroa, Joseph Flavian Gomes, Simon Handreke, Duncan Hay, Brian Higgins, Rebekah Higgitt, Ruixue Jia, Mounir Karadja, Marie Kaul, Martin Koenen, Julius Koschnick, Lukas Leucht, Moritz Lubczyk, Andreas Madestam, Jaakko Meriläinen, Joel Mokyr, Arash Nekoei, J. Peter Nilsson, Artschil Okropiridse, Anders Olofsgård, Casey Petroff, Alessandro Pizzigolotto, Prashant Poddar, Luca Repetto, Jonatan Riberth, Veronica Salazar Restrepo, Theo Serlin, Lina Skoglund, Mara P.
Squicciarini, Anna Tompsett, Karine van der Beek, Miriam Venturini, Noam Yuchtman, and Yves Zenou, as well as audiences at IIES, Oxford, Stockholm, Toulouse, the 15th Workshop on Growth, History and Development in Odense, the 4th Workshop in Economic History in Uppsala, SUDSWEC 2025, the EAYE 2026 Annual Meeting, the RIDGE Forum 2026, the SIOE 2026 Conference, the Applied Young Economists’ Webinar 2026, and the 4th Yale-UB HPE Workshop for valuable feedback, help, and, not least, encouragement. †IIES, Stockholm University. monir.bounadi@iies.su.se · www.monirbounadi.com ‡Kiel Institute for the World Economy. jens.oehlen@ifw-kiel.de · jensoehlen.github.io 1. INTRODUCTION Producing new knowledge depends on how much of the existing knowledge stock researchers can access (Iaria et al., 2018; Mokyr, 2002). Though much of the existing knowledge is accessible in print or online, frontier knowledge often contains tacit elements that are difficult to articulate, making face-to-face interaction important for their transmission (Polanyi, 1966). Tacit knowledge is likely to be particularly important in periods when the scientific frontier changes rapidly (e.g., Shapin and Schaffer, 1985).
Moreover, access to tacit knowledge depends on access to the relevant social networks, whose formation is shaped by culture, geography, education, family background, and wealth (e.g., Bourdieu, 1986; Glaeser et al., 1992; Jaffe et al., 1993). Institutions shape who gains that access. On the one hand, institutions such as universities filter access to knowledge exchange to maintain quality and organize exchange within specialized, coordinated communities. On the other, such filtering narrows the pool of potential researchers.
Broadening access could raise knowledge production and use by drawing in a reserve of talent that would otherwise be lost (e.g., Agarwal and Gaule, 2020; Bell et al., 2019; Husén, 1974; Stephan, 1996), especially when those outside filtering institutions possess valuable, tacit know-how. Yet, broadened access is seldom random, and we rarely have data to trace long-run effects. This paper exploits the rise of a new social institution in English society, the coffeehouse, to overcome these difficulties. It was one of several such institutions during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, alongside French salons and German table societies, which are credited as transformative developments in early modern Europe (e.g., Clark, 2000; Cowan, 2005; Mokyr, 2016).
Habermas (1991 [1962]) placed their introduction at the origin of the bourgeois “public sphere,” and singled out the coffeehouse as a catalyst of Enlightenment thinking, a public, interactive, middle-class space where reason, rather than social rank, shaped debate. The coffeehouse “not merely made access to the relevant circles less formal and easier; it embraced the wider strata of the middle class, including craftsmen and shopkeepers” (Habermas, 1991 [1962], p. 33). Mokyr (2005) argues that coffeehouses, among other social institutions, reduced access costs to “useful knowledge” oriented toward progress at the intersection of science and technology. This paper asks whether coffeehouses fostered intellectual progress by broadening access and, if so, how.
We answer these questions by studying coffeehouses and science in seventeenth- century London, home to one of the first coffeehouses in Europe in 1652 and a center of the Scientific Revolution. In this context, much of the new experimental science relied on tacit knowledge. Its experiments ran on scientific instruments, and the skill to make them lay with craftsmen who learned it by apprenticeship and rarely wrote it down. Coffeehouses spread suddenly and unevenly, parish by parish, from the first in 1652, and rich historical records track scientific activity over the subsequent decades.
For the price of a cup of coffee, a penny or about one-tenth of a day’s wage, strangers conversed across social ranks, earning coffeehouses their famous nickname, “penny universities” (Ellis, 1956). In the analysis to follow, we focus on their effects on mathematical practitioners, the applied scientists of the period, recorded as teaching mathematics, writing on it, or making instruments, and on the shops that made, repaired, and sold those instruments.1 Their work, seeking understanding while shaped by use, is what 1Instead of counting applied scientists, several studies of institutions and knowledge measure 1 Stokes (1997) would call use-inspired basic research. The idea that coffeehouses broadened access to knowledge dates to John Houghton (1645–1705), a Fellow of the Royal Society, who observed (1727 [1701], p. 132): Coffee-houses make all sorts of people sociable, the rich and the poor meet together, as also do the learned and unlearned: It improves arts, merchandize, and all other knowledge; for here an inquisitive man [. . .] may get more in an evening than he shall by Books in a month. We take Houghton’s thesis to the historical record.
To do so, we hand-geocode every coffeehouse, mathematical practitioner workplace, and scientific instrument shop with a recorded address, using digitized seventeenth-century maps and gazetteers. This places these records within the 162 parishes of London and yields a parish-by-decade panel from the 1600s through the 1690s. We also use practitioners’ biographies to reconstruct the social connections between them, from friendship and apprenticeship to correspondence and consultation. Coffeehouses, practitioners, and instrument shops come from three separate compilations assembled from different historical records by different authors, so our results are not merely an artifact of a single work or author.
We begin by estimating, in a staggered event study design, the effect of the first coffeehouse in a parish. We find that its opening is followed by a persistent increase in mathematical practitioners and scientific instrument shops. We then trace the channels. Effects are concentrated among practitioners with weak family ties to Oxford and Cambridge, connections increase between practitioners with craft skill and those with the knowledge to teach and develop theory, and new shops turn toward experimental instruments.
Beyond London, applied mathematics titles and scientific instrument makers also rise after the first coffeehouse in European cities, relative to cities of similar size and growth. Finally, in a quantitative urban model, coffeehouses account for 31 percent of London’s applied scientists between the 1650s and the 1690s. These results suggest that institutions need not codify knowledge or screen members to raise its production. An open venue for conversation could do so by broadening access to intellectual exchange beyond formal academic networks.
As Figure 1 shows, coffeehouses appeared when a sustained rise in the number of practitioners and instrument shops began. These trends coincided with a cultural shift toward quantification. Kelly and Ó Gráda (2022) show that the publication of applied mathematics titles more than doubled in the 1650s, interpreting this as a rise in demand as navigational and surveying technologies came into widespread use. In the same decade, language oriented toward progress began to rise (Almelhem et al., 2026).2 Historians likewise document these shifts and emphasize coffeehouses as a central driver of them (e.g., Ellis, 2006; Jacob, 1997), but without providing quantitative evidence.
However, the staggered and incomplete distribution of coffeehouses within London helps separate the effect of these venues from rising aggregate demand. The parishes of innovation with patents (e.g., Berkes and Nencka, 2026; Cinnirella et al., 2025; Hanlon et al., 2022). However, using patents is not feasible here. Of the 365 English patents of 1617–1699 in the data of Berkes et al. (2026), 34 name a patentee in London and five concern instruments or timekeepers, against 345 instrument shops in our London data.
Instrument making relied on secrecy. Even at the Great Exhibition of 1851, only 10 percent of British instrument exhibits were patented (Moser, 2013). 2Appendix Figure D19 adds applied mathematics titles and the average progress score in England to Figure 1. 2 0 20 40 60 80 100 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700 Coffeehouses Mathematical practitioners Scientific instrument shops Figure 1. Coffeehouses and science Notes: Figure plots the number of coffeehouses, mathematical practitioners, and scientific instrument shops active in each year in seventeenth-century London. Coffeehouses are from Lillywhite (1963, 1972), practitioners from Taylor (1954), and instrument shops from Clifton (1995) and Hay et al. (2025). [Return to pages 2, OA-7, OA-81] London are small units, and 97 of the 162 lie within the City walls alone, so a parish that received a coffeehouse and one that did not were often only a few streets apart.
Of the 162 parishes, 101 have no coffeehouse recorded before 1700. We compare activity before and after the first recorded coffeehouse with changes in these never-treated parishes, using the staggered, heterogeneity-robust event study estimator of Wooldridge (2023). We find large and persistent local effects on both measures of scientific activity. The 61 treated parishes averaged 0.62 mathematical practitioners in the decade before entry, and over the decade of entry and the four decades after, the number roughly doubles, to 1.30.
Scientific instrument shops also rise, from 0.33 to 1.57, or nearly fivefold. Despite data scarcity, these effects are precisely estimated and significant. On growth, from the 1640s to
Texto de monirbounadi.com tal como lo publicó, leído de su página y mostrado aquí con el formato de El Autómata. El original, en monirbounadi.com · Volver a la noticia de El Autómata